Fabulous dinner specials and nightly entertainment

Located in the "Gem of the Florida Keys", the Key Colony Inn is a local and tourist favorite, serving only the finest Florida Keys seafood. Our menu is seasoned with delicious French and Italian favorites - from succulent lobster and shrimp over angel hair pasta to steak au poivre, veal cutlets, and fresh yellowtail snapper. The family-owned Key Colony Inn has been voted Best Restaurant for 15 years in a row!
Feast in our intimate main dining room or spacious patio, or enjoy live, nightly entertainment in our romantic lounge, while sipping on a vintage wine, frozen libation, or our famous "Espresso Martini".

We are also proud to offer the largest brunch in the islands, featuring dishes like stuffed shells, yellowtail in a lemon dill sauce, eggs benedict, pancakes and custom omelets.

Stop in for dinner or lunch, we'll be expecting you.

- Sergei & Lena

Let us host your special event

Your special day requires a special venue, and our spacious and private dining room features cathedral ceilings and glass doors overlooking tropical landscaping and the island's popular golf course.
Designed for a myriad of events like weddings, birthday parties, benefits, conventions and corporate engagements, the Key Colony Inn's friendly staff is ready to provide your guests with the most gracious service imaginable.
Whether you order from our award-winning menu, or order your own buffet, the Key Colony Inn will ensure your event will be an occasion your guests will treasure for year to come!

Click here for more information and event reservations.

Key Colony Inn photos


Open 7 days ~ Lunch & Dinner
Eat in or Take out

Featuring fresh local seafood, fine steaks & delicious pastas with a full bar and an extensive wine list.
Click here for our full menu!

Don't forget Sunday Brunch!
Join us for brunch on Easter and Mother's Day.


More than 50 food items to choose from, including our delicious Pasta a la Sergei, eggs benedict, fresh fruit and more...

coupon Click to print coupon.
We are unable to accept digital coupons!

The Espresso Martini
A delicious blend of fresh brewed espresso, Tia Maria, Kahlua and our secret dark vodka. A KCI legend!
The Ultimate Cosmo
Three olives, citrus and a splash of cranberry juice!
Island Blue
Three Olives Vanilla Vodka highlighted with DeKuyper Island Blue Pucker. A martini made for the tropics.
BayBreeze Martini
Svedka Vodka with splashes of cranberry and pineapple juices.
and others...